Warming up…
About this Board
On Wednesday, October 21, 1 player took on MLB Deep Cut #28: “Name a player who hit 2+ home runs in a postseason game since 2000.” The prompt had 95 valid answers, and players found 1 of them. Correct answers score more the fewer people name them, so the deepest cuts are the ones worth the most.
Answers and recap (spoilers)
The most popular answer was Shohei Ohtani, named by 100% of players. Nobody found the day's Sleeper: Manuel Margot.
Named by players
- Shohei Ohtani (Shohei Ohtani (DH · LAA, LAD · 2018–2025)): 1 player, 100%, 35 points. Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2025 playoffs)
Nobody named
- Carlos Beltran: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2012 playoffs)
- Albert Pujols: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Chase Utley: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2009 playoffs)
- Adrian Beltre: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Miguel Cabrera: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Chipper Jones: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2003 playoffs)
- David Ortiz: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2013 playoffs)
- Manny Ramirez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2005 playoffs)
- Johnny Damon: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2004 playoffs)
- Nick Castellanos: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
- Jayson Werth: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2009 playoffs)
- George Springer: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Jeff Kent: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2002 playoffs)
- Marcell Ozuna: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Jason Giambi: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2003 playoffs)
- Jose Altuve: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2017 playoffs)
- Enrique Hernandez: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2017 playoffs)
- Frank Thomas: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2006 playoffs)
- Raul Ibanez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2012 playoffs)
- Troy Glaus: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2002 playoffs)
- Aramis Ramirez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2003 playoffs)
- Nelson Cruz: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Carlos Correa: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Kyle Schwarber: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2025 playoffs)
- Scott Rolen: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2004 playoffs)
- Evan Longoria: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2008 playoffs)
- A.J. Pierzynski: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2005 playoffs)
- Larry Walker: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2004 playoffs)
- Carlos Delgado: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2006 playoffs)
- Adrian Gonzalez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2013 playoffs)
- Jhonny Peralta: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2012 playoffs)
- Bryce Harper: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
- Shawn Green: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2004 playoffs)
- Magglio Ordonez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2006 playoffs)
- Russell Martin: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2013 playoffs)
- Giancarlo Stanton: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Jose Bautista: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2015 playoffs)
- Carl Crawford: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2013 playoffs)
- Eric Karros: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2003 playoffs)
- Adam Kennedy: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2002 playoffs)
- Pat Burrell: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2008 playoffs)
- Teoscar Hernandez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2025 playoffs)
- Ryan Howard: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2008 playoffs)
- Rich Aurilia: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2002 playoffs)
- Tim Salmon: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2002 playoffs)
- Dustin Pedroia: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2008 playoffs)
- Eugenio Suarez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2025 playoffs)
- Michael Brantley Jr.: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Mike Napoli: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2008 playoffs)
- Melvin Upton: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2008 playoffs)
- Pablo Sandoval: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2012 playoffs)
- Chris Young: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Javier Baez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2017 playoffs)
- Jose Abreu: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
- Kendrys Morales: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2015 playoffs)
- Hideki Matsui: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2004 playoffs)
- Alex Gonzalez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2003 playoffs)
- Chris Taylor: Best postseason game since 2000: 3 home runs (2021 playoffs)
- Corey Seager: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Todd Walker: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2003 playoffs)
- Yordan Alvarez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
- Delmon Young: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Eddie Rosario: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2021 playoffs)
- A.J. Pollock: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2021 playoffs)
- Michael Conforto: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2015 playoffs)
- Josh Hamilton: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2010 playoffs)
- Didi Gregorius: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2017 playoffs)
- Jorge Polanco: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2025 playoffs)
- Wil Myers: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Cody Ross: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2010 playoffs)
- Milton Bradley: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2006 playoffs)
- Brandon Moss: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2014 playoffs)
- Kyle Tucker: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2022 playoffs)
- Fernando Tatis Jr.: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2024 playoffs)
- Manuel Margot: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Yandy Diaz: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2019 playoffs)
- Gary Sanchez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2018 playoffs)
- Rhys Hoskins: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2022 playoffs)
- Terrence Long: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2001 playoffs)
- Brandon Lowe: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Steve Pearce: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2018 playoffs)
- Adolis Garcia: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
- Ramon Laureano: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Daulton Varsho: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2025 playoffs)
- Alejandro Kirk: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2025 playoffs)
- Danny Jansen: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2020 playoffs)
- Desmond Jennings: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Kelly Shoppach: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2011 playoffs)
- Roberto Perez: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2016 playoffs)
- Josh Jung: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
- Andy Pages: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2024 playoffs)
- Mark Vientos: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2024 playoffs)
- Jackson Chourio: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2024 playoffs)
- Royce Lewis: Best postseason game since 2000: 2 home runs (2023 playoffs)
Missed it? Every past day is in the MLB archive, ready to play blind. Here’s how scoring works.