Warming up…

About this Board

On Wednesday, November 18, 77 players took on NFL Deep Cut #56: “Name a first-round pick in the 2004 NFL Draft who played in the NFL.” The prompt had 32 valid answers, and players found 17 of them. Correct answers score more the fewer people name them, so the deepest cuts are the ones worth the most.

Answers and recap (spoilers)

The most popular answer was Eli Manning, named by 29% of players. The rarest correct answer anyone found was Marcus Tubbs (1 player, 78 points). Nobody found the day's Sleeper: Vernon Carey.

Named by players

  1. Eli Manning (Eli Manning (QB · NYG · 2004–2019)): 22 players, 29%, 5 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 1
  2. Ben Roethlisberger (Ben Roethlisberger (QB · PIT · 2004–2021)): 21 players, 27%, 5 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 11
  3. Philip Rivers (Philip Rivers (QB · LAC, IND · 2004–2025)): 18 players, 23%, 5 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 4
  4. Larry Fitzgerald (Larry Fitzgerald (WR · ARI · 2004–2020)): 5 players, 7%, 13 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 3
  5. Vince Wilfork (Vince Wilfork (NT · NE, HOU · 2004–2016)): 3 players, 4%, 21 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 21
  6. Benjamin Watson (Benjamin Watson (TE · NE, CLE, NO, BAL, NO, NE · 2004–2019)): 3 players, 4%, 21 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 32
  7. Steven Jackson (Steven Jackson (RB · LA, ATL, NE · 2004–2015)): 2 players, 3%, 30 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 24
  8. Rashaun Woods (Rashaun Woods (WR · SF · 2004)): 2 players, 3%, 48 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 31
  9. DeAngelo Hall (DeAngelo Hall (S · ATL, LV, WAS · 2004–2017)): 1 player, 1%, 35 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 8
  10. Dunta Robinson (Dunta Robinson (CB · HOU, ATL, KC · 2004–2013)): 1 player, 1%, 40 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 10
  11. Chris Gamble (Chris Gamble (CB · CAR · 2004–2012)): 1 player, 1%, 43 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 28
  12. Roy Williams (Roy Williams (WR · DET, DAL, CHI · 2004–2011)): 1 player, 1%, 45 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 7
  13. Reggie Williams (Reggie Williams (WR · JAX · 2004–2008)): 1 player, 1%, 55 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 9
  14. Sean Taylor (Sean Taylor (FS · WAS · 2004–2007)): 1 player, 1%, 63 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 5
  15. Kenechi Udeze (Kenechi Udeze (DE · MIN · 2004–2007)): 1 player, 1%, 65 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 20
  16. Chris Perry (Chris Perry (RB · CIN · 2004–2008)): 1 player, 1%, 75 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 26
  17. Marcus Tubbs (Marcus Tubbs (DT · SEA · 2004–2006)): 1 player, 1%, 78 points. Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 23

Nobody named

  • Will Smith: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 18
  • D.J. Williams: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 17
  • Jonathan Vilma: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 12
  • Jason Babin: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 27
  • Michael Jenkins: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 29
  • Lee Evans: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 13
  • Tommie Harris: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 14
  • Kellen Winslow: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 6
  • Michael Clayton: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 15
  • Robert Gallery: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 2
  • Kevin Jones: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 30
  • Ahmad Carroll: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 25
  • Vernon Carey: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 19
  • J.P. Losman: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 22
  • Shawn Andrews: Drafted 2004, round 1, pick 16

Missed it? Every past day is in the NFL archive, ready to play blind. Here’s how scoring works.